Feasibility Analysis and Comparative Advantage Analysis
There are many analysis techniques that are useful to us in the domain of Strategic Alignment. In this video we'll start things off with a reminder of feasibility analysis, and how a comparative advantage analysis might be useful.
As promised, here's the cheat sheet for some of the financial measures formulas:
This is a great article explaining Comparative Advantage, including the Michael Jordan house painting example:
Knowledge Check
What does the concept of comparative advantage explain?
SWOT and PESTEL Analysis
SWOT and PESTEL are useful both at the beginning of our program as well as throughout the entire lifecycle. They are invaluable frameworks for uncovering factors which might impact the success of our program. Let's learn how.
Knowledge Check
The T in SWOT represents
Knowledge Check
The T in PESTEL reprsents
Assumption, Historical, Trend, and Scenario Analysis
Let's wrap up our exploration of different analysis techniques with the last 4 on our list!
Knowledge Check
Match up the analysis technique with how it might be used:
This interactive assessment is available in the full learning experience.
Here's the full lineup of analysis techniques for your reference:
Applying Skills and Knowledge to Strategic Alignment
The PMI suggests many skills and areas of knowledge which are important for strategic alignment. Let's take a look at just a few of them in this next video.
Here's the exam content outline referenced in the video:
Knowledge Check
Which is the best definition of a brainstorm?
Challenge
In this section, you'll see a variety of tasks which we might expect a program manager to carry out in the domain of Strategic Alignment. Take a look at them and see if you can fill in the gaps for the missing words. This summarises the key points from the Strategic Alignment performance domain, and therefore also covers concepts introduced in the previous skill. You can watch the video afterwards if you need further explanations.
Task 1
Knowledge Check
What word(s) fill the gap?
Task 2
Knowledge Check
What word(s) fill in the gap?
Task 3
Knowledge Check
What words(s) fill the gap?
Task 4
Knowledge Check
What word(s) fill the gap?
Task 5
Knowledge Check
What words fill the gaps?
View Transcript
Feasibility Analysis and Comparative Advantage Analysis
0:00If you're studying for the PMI's program management professional certification,
0:05then
0:05there are going to be a few things in the domain of strategic alignment that
0:08you've
0:08either spotted on the exam content outline or in the standard for program
0:12management
0:13that might be making you think to yourself, "Hmm, I think I need a bit more
0:16information
0:17here to help me prepare for the exam."
0:19And I didn't want to side track us too much on this extra information when we
0:22were looking
0:23at strategic alignment generally in the last skill, but that's what this skill
0:27is all about.
0:28Starting off with some analysis techniques that we might use in the strategic
0:32alignment
0:33performance domain, including the ones that I vaguely wafted in front of you
0:37when we were
0:38talking about the business case and the environmental assessment elements of
0:42the domain.
0:43And the particular techniques I would like us to consider in varying degrees of
0:47detail
0:47are the ones that you can see appearing here.
0:50And it is a lot, yes, but we will talk about each one and then we're going to
0:53build up
0:54this slide with a summary of each one so that you've got an overall summary to
0:58take away
0:58with you.
0:59And I'm going to start you off gently with the feasibility analysis.
1:03And I say starting off gently because we've kind of already talked about this,
1:06haven't
1:06we?
1:07Because this is sounding remarkably like the business case.
1:09So the business case is a documented economic feasibility study, of course.
1:13So we have talked about that and we also know that it's going to be including
1:17some kind
1:17of cost benefit analysis.
1:19So that's what that little, the scales graphic there.
1:21We're weighing up the costs that we're spending with the benefits that we
1:25expect to achieve.
1:26And here's a reminder of that slide we saw before for those different measures
1:30for cost
1:31benefit analysis.
1:32And in the interests of this skill being all about giving you a bit more
1:36information
1:36to help you with the exam, what I have done, and I've given you this document
1:40in this skill,
1:41is created just a little cheat sheet for you.
1:45Because I'm very aware that I didn't want to sidetrack too much on giving you
1:48all the
1:48detail and all of these different financial measures for possibly relatively
1:52few questions
1:53in the exam where you might have to calculate these.
1:56Some of you will know this already from having studied for the PMP.
1:59But if you're not feeling very comfortable with this, you might be thinking, oh
2:02, well,
2:03if I was going to put a bit of effort into learning something to help me with
2:05these financial
2:06measures, what should that be?
2:07Well, that's what this cheat sheet is all about.
2:09This is kind of what I think is the minimum that you should perhaps be studying
2:13if you
2:13did need to fill in a few gaps around these financial measures and whatnot.
2:17So you've got that document to work through if you need to.
2:20But what I would like to draw your attention to ready for the next analysis
2:23technique is
2:24opportunity cost.
2:25So do you remember we talked about that as being a consideration in our cost
2:29benefit
2:30analysis because we do have to consider what are we giving up in order to
2:33invest in this
2:34one or what are our people not doing if they're doing tasks related to this
2:39initiative.
2:40So there's an opportunity cost that's always there to be considered.
2:43So hold that thought because next on our list for analysis techniques is
2:47comparative advantage
2:49analysis.
2:51Now comparative advantage is an economy's ability to produce a particular good
2:56or service
2:57at a lower opportunity cost than its trading partners.
3:01Now you'll notice I haven't written up that definition for you and you might be
3:04thinking,
3:05oh, that has blown my mind.
3:07But don't worry, this is a term used in economics.
3:10But for us though, I just want us to think of it as a tool that might be useful
3:14to supplement
3:15a feasibility analysis.
3:17So it does lead us on quite well from the feasibility analysis.
3:20And if you're wondering why I've got a picture of a man painting a house here,
3:24well that's
3:24because I'm going to skip straight to an example to explain the principle of
3:28comparative advantage
3:30rather than trying to give you an economics lesson.
3:33So I've gone to the investor PDA website here.
3:37I highly recommend this if you want more background information and I have
3:40given you this link.
3:41It's a fantastic resource for anything to do with finances and investing and
3:45economics
3:46and whatnot.
3:47And I really did like the article on comparative advantage.
3:50So this is your resource if you do want more background information.
3:53But I am going to hop straight to the example because I thought this was really
3:56rather brilliant
3:57and I thought to myself, well, rather than trying to dream up my own example,
4:01why don't
4:02I just use the one that's explained really rather well on this website.
4:05And in fact, let me just zoom in a bit to the actual text so that I can talk
4:09you through
4:09this.
4:10So first paragraph here, as an example, we're going to consider a famous
4:14athlete such as
4:15Michael Jordan.
4:17So as a renowned basketball and baseball star, Michael Jordan is an exceptional
4:22athlete whose
4:23physical abilities surpass those of most other individuals.
4:27So therefore Michael Jordan would likely be able to say, paint his house pretty
4:32quickly,
4:33owing to his abilities as well as his impressive height.
4:36So that's why I had that little graphic of a man painting a house.
4:39So what we're saying here is that Michael Jordan could of course paint his own
4:44house
4:44pretty well.
4:45He would do a perfectly good job at painting his own house.
4:48And because he's an athlete, he's going to have the physical stamina and the
4:52height to
4:52actually do a rather good job.
4:54But if we look at the first part of paragraph two here, so yes, let's say
4:59Michael Jordan
5:00could paint his house in eight hours, but in the same eight hours, he could
5:05also potentially
5:06take part in the filming of a TV commercial, which would earn him $50,000.
5:12So yes, although he could paint the house himself, in the same time it would
5:16take him,
5:17he could actually earn loads of money.
5:19So that represents a really high opportunity cost, doesn't it, for Michael
5:24Jordan?
5:24So if you move on to the second part of this second paragraph.
5:27So by contrast, Jordan's neighbour Joe could paint Jordan's house in maybe 10
5:32hours, so
5:33he could pay Joe to do it.
5:35And in that same time period, Joe could have worked at a fast food restaurant
5:39and earn
5:39$100.
5:40So that's what Joe would be missing out on.
5:42If he painted Jordan's house for him, you know, that's what he would miss out
5:45on.
5:45That's the opportunity he would be foregoing.
5:47If he painted Jordan's house for him, he'd miss out on that $100 wage for
5:51working at the
5:52fast food restaurant.
5:54And that is a much lower opportunity cost, isn't it, than Michael Jordan's
5:57opportunity
5:58cost.
5:59So therefore, this is where the idea of comparative advantage comes in.
6:04Joe has a comparative advantage due to his lower opportunity cost.
6:09Despite the fact that Michael Jordan could possibly do it faster and better.
6:14So the best trade would be for Michael Jordan to go ahead and film his TV
6:18commercial to
6:18earn all that money and pay Joe to paint his house.
6:21But here's the clincher.
6:23As long as Michael does indeed make the expected $50,000 and as long as Joe
6:29earns more than
6:30the $100 for the work he's missing out on, then the trade is a winner.
6:34We've got a win-win situation here.
6:37So that's comparative advantage.
6:39And so for us, as I say, don't let it blow your mind when we hear the
6:42definition talk
6:43about trading partners in an economy.
6:45No, for us, this kind of analysis is going to support the cost benefit analysis
6:49in the
6:50business case.
6:51So we understand our opportunity costs.
6:53We understand what work it makes sense to outsource, that kind of thing.
6:57And speaking personally, when I was a freelance trainer and copywriter, I'd be
7:01doing all sorts
7:02of odd jobs on a freelance basis for lots of different clients.
7:05I would always be considering, well, okay, this particular work I've been
7:08offered on,
7:09this particular date, that will pay me a certain amount.
7:12I traded off against other work I might get offered.
7:15It's a useful way to understand what work we should take on, what work we
7:18should not
7:19take on, and what work we could outsource.
7:21And looking at the time, I think we should take a pause there and wait for the
7:24next video
7:25to talk about the next couple of analysis techniques.
SWOT and PESTEL Analysis
0:00Having looked at feasibility analysis and the idea of comparative advantage in
0:04the last video,
0:05in this video I'd like us to tackle SWAT and PESTEL.
0:09Now the SWAT analysis is going to be really useful to help us assess various
0:14internal and external factors or forces
0:17that are having an impact on our program and certainly in the context of risk
0:22analysis
0:22we're going to be using a SWAT analysis to help us identify risks and what they
0:25might mean to us
0:26and the SWAT analysis will also absolutely be on our list of tools when it
0:30comes to performing the environmental assessments
0:33that we talked about in the strategic align domain skill.
0:36But also the SWAT analysis will play an important part in putting together the
0:41business case.
0:42So let's take a look at it.
0:44So SWAT SWOT comes from these four words here, strengths, weaknesses,
0:49opportunities and threats.
0:51So we're examining factors which represent these four areas here.
0:56And strengths and weaknesses tend to be described as things internal to our
1:01organization
1:02whereas opportunities and threats tend to be things external to our
1:05organization.
1:06You'll see some examples in a second.
1:08While the left-hand side, the strengths and opportunities are seen to be things
1:12that are positive,
1:12you know, they're going to help us out when it comes to our program
1:15and then the right-hand side are the negatives.
1:17Those are the things that could be causing us a problem or could be holding us
1:21back.
1:21So let's look at a few examples.
1:23So when it comes to looking at strengths, we're asking ourselves,
1:26"Well, what gives us a competitive advantage?
1:29What have we got on our side here that's going to help us with this program or
1:32this initiative?"
1:33So it might be something like, "Yay, we've successfully delivered two other
1:37very similar initiatives."
1:39You know, that's a strength.
1:40We've got form.
1:41We've proved that we can do this.
1:43But that also could lead us to understand what weaknesses we might have.
1:47So having understood, yeah, that's a good strength.
1:49We've done this before.
1:50We might then realize, "Hmm, perhaps we're too reliant on certain key team
1:54members."
1:55So our weaknesses are all about properties to our internal environment that
1:59might cause us a problem.
2:00So yeah, we might be reliant on some key team members and if they were to leave
2:04,
2:04that is going to cause us a problem.
2:06So that's a weakness.
2:07Opportunities, however, is where we look at what situations or trends or
2:12circumstances around us,
2:13you know, outside of our organization, you know, what other things are going on
2:17that might be a reason for us to pursue this particular initiative and, you
2:21know,
2:21have a good outcome with it.
2:22So it might be something like, "We've identified an opportunity whereby,
2:26if we qualify as an educational program, we might get funding."
2:30So I was using this example.
2:32I mean, let's imagine we're putting together a language learning app and let's
2:36say our local
2:36government does have grants available for people putting together learning
2:39resources.
2:40You know, we might qualify for that extra funding.
2:42That's an opportunity that could help us out if we decided to pursue this
2:46particular initiative.
2:47Whereas threats, of course, are negative things.
2:51They are things that might be happening in the world around us that could cause
2:54us a problem.
2:54So something like, " Potential new legislation could slow down our processes."
2:58There might be changes to the way we have to do things that are going to cause
3:02us a problem,
3:02that's going to threaten our productivity, it's going to threaten our
3:05profitability,
3:06it's going to threaten the success of our, you know, of our initiative.
3:10So as you can see, the SWOT analysis is a tool to help us organize important
3:15factors into these
3:15four categories here.
3:17And these four categories are really useful indicators of success or failure of
3:21a business
3:21initiative.
3:22So it's a way for us to establish a clear and common understanding of various
3:27categories of
3:27influences that are going to impact the success of our program.
3:30And it's a really useful technique that we can use to get a brainstorming
3:34session flowing
3:34when we are trying to identify risks or trying to understand whether this is
3:38indeed a good
3:39business opportunity to pursue.
3:40But we do need the right people in the room to do that brainstorming session
3:44and it certainly
3:45needs to be well facilitated.
3:46So that's probably the program manager that's facilitating this session.
3:49So it needs to be well run.
3:51We also need to make sure that we are honest when we do our SWOT analysis,
3:55particularly when it comes to, for example, looking for our weaknesses, looking
3:59internally
3:59at ourselves.
4:00What are our weaknesses in terms of considering whether this is a good
4:03initiative to pursue?
4:04So we have to be honest.
4:05And although the SWOT analysis is really common at the very beginning of a
4:09program
4:10when we're initiating it, we should also repeat it periodically when the
4:14program is underway
4:15to assess what's changed and therefore what that means for our program in terms
4:18of strategic
4:19alignment.
4:20So that's our SWOT analysis.
4:22Next on the list we've got PESTLE analysis.
4:25And again, this provides a mechanism or perhaps framework is a better word for
4:31analyzing
4:31the environment from many different angles, six of them to be precise.
4:35And this will be a perfect technique to use for our environmental assessment
4:39element of the strategic alignment performance domain.
4:42And it is a mnemonic PESTLE to help us remember these six categories of
4:45external factors,
4:46which of course we shall go through.
4:48So the P stands for political.
4:51So this is where we're looking at things like government stability and how that
4:55might
4:55impact our program.
4:56We're looking at any political policies such as trade deals.
5:00In fact, here in the UK, when we left Brexit a few years ago now,
5:04that had a big impact on businesses in terms of how they could actually trade
5:08with the European
5:09Union.
5:10And it's going to be things like any taxation changes.
5:13Different governments might have different opinions on how it comes to taxing
5:16different
5:17industries and whatnot.
5:18And of course that taxation changes suggestion leads me on to the E and the E
5:23is for economic.
5:24So this is where we're talking about inflation and economic growth.
5:28You know, it's going to be things like interest rates and currency rates.
5:31All of these kinds of things happening around us in terms of the economy
5:35and finance might have an impact.
5:37It's certainly worthy for consideration when we're looking at a particular
5:40initiative or a program.
5:41The S stands for social.
5:44So this is where we will be looking at population trends.
5:47We might be looking at demographics of our audience, of our customer base.
5:51We're going to be understanding cultural trends.
5:53We'll be taking a look at lifestyle changes.
5:55The T is for technological.
5:58So of course, this is where we're looking at advancements and innovations
6:01that are happening around us that might impact how we go about doing our
6:04business,
6:05how or if we go ahead and do this program.
6:08It's also going to be helping us to understand what new capabilities could
6:11either help us
6:12or compete with us when it comes to putting together whatever service or
6:15product we're trying
6:16to put together.
6:17And also what trends in the field of technology that we might need to
6:20understand or to support.
6:22So for example, things being cloud based people expect to be able to access
6:26services
6:26from their phones from from any device.
6:28So therefore, that's a trend in the world of technology that we should consider
6:32supporting
6:32in whatever product or service we're putting together.
6:35The second E of our list here, well, that stands for environmental.
6:39So this is going to be things like sustainability and our carbon footprint.
6:43It's all about climate change and responsibility and respect for the world
6:47around us in terms
6:48of the environment and, you know, our waste disposable or recycling efforts.
6:52And this could apply to either our processes internally and or the product that
6:57we are producing.
6:58The L, well, that stands for legal.
7:01So this is where we're talking about things like data privacy policies or it
7:05could be health
7:06and safety policies, anything like that that's going to impact how we do work,
7:10how we carry out
7:10our business, how we capture data, how we implement our processes.
7:14It could be other consumer rights or even labor rights.
7:17And yes, that is how we spell labor here in the UK.
7:20And there are going to be other industry or local regulations that we need to
7:23abide by as well.
7:25But many of these factors here will be interrelated.
7:27So for example, political policies might drive the industry and local
7:31regulations that we have
7:33to abide by, which in turn might set standards for how we perform our waste
7:37disposal and what
7:39particular carbon footprint we should be trying to achieve or a booming economy
7:43might drive
7:44certain lifestyle changes. So they are interwoven, but very much like a SWOT
7:49analysis,
7:49the PESTLE framework does give us a good framework for brainstorming.
7:53So this is going to be invaluable for our environmental assessments and for
7:56risk identification.
7:58But again, like the SWOT analysis, these sessions need to be well facilitated
8:02with everybody understanding the purpose of the brainstorming session and we
8:05need to have
8:06the right people in the room as well. So there we go. That's SWOT and PESTLE.
8:10Stand by for the next video where we will tackle the last four of our list.
Assumption, Historical, Trend, and Scenario Analysis
0:00Okay, we've checked the first four off our list here and I reckon the last four
0:04here
0:04we can tackle all in one video. So we shall begin this video then with
0:08assumption analysis.
0:10And this is where we explore the validity of any assumptions made. So let's
0:14consider
0:15this, starting by making sure we understand what we mean by an assumption. So
0:19an assumption
0:19is something that we consider to be true for planning purposes. But critical in
0:24that
0:25sentence there is that we consider something to be true, but it's not actually
0:29necessarily
0:30true. We don't have any proof or confirmation that it is actually true. I mean
0:33it might
0:33be true, but you know, we're not certain that it is. But why do we need
0:37assumptions?
0:38Well, the idea is we make assumptions in order to fit in the gaps when
0:41information is not
0:43yet available because at the early stages we might not have all of the
0:46information that
0:47we need to be able to have definitive figures and values and the effort spent
0:52in confirming
0:53or proving something might outweigh the benefit of actually having it, whatever
0:56it is. So we
0:57use these best effort judgments to help us move forward with our planning
1:01because we
1:02don't want to hit a hard stop just because we don't know for sure exactly how
1:06much something
1:07is going to cost or exactly how long something will take. Sometimes we just
1:11need to make
1:12an intelligent guess and use that guess as a basis for further planning. That's
1:17an assumption.
1:18So for example, when we're putting together our business case, you know, we
1:22need to have
1:22some kind of cost estimate. Well, that is just a cost estimate. And as part of
1:27putting
1:27together that cost estimate, we will have made certain assumptions such as
1:32assuming that
1:33we need for developers costing however many dollars, then we estimate the cost
1:37is going
1:37to be whatever it is. Or what about when we're putting together our draft
1:41financial framework?
1:42Again, we're making assumptions. We might say assuming that we do continue to
1:46receive
1:47funding as an educational provider, blah, blah, blah. You know, that has
1:51certain implications
1:51as to how we expect the flow of funds to actually pan out throughout the life
1:55cycle of our program.
1:58But here's the thing about assumptions. They might be wrong. You know, it's
2:02something that
2:03we are considering to be true, but without any proof or confirmation. And so
2:08the point,
2:08therefore, of assumptions analysis, well, actually, it's twofold. So firstly,
2:14because
2:14we have an assumption, what risk might they introduce if that assumption turns
2:19out to be wrong?
2:21So the assumption I gave you as an example a second ago, so assuming that we
2:24continue
2:25to receive funding, blah, blah, blah, well, that is just an assumption. So
2:28therefore,
2:29there is a risk that that assumption turns out to be wrong. And therefore, we
2:32don't continue
2:33to receive funding. So that is something that we need to consider as part of
2:37our risk
2:37identification and risk analysis. So that's the first element of assumptions
2:42analysis.
2:42What risk might they introduce if they turn out to be wrong? But secondly, as
2:46we progress
2:47through the program, are these assumptions still valid? So we might have
2:51originally assumed that,
2:53yeah, we think we need four developers costing a certain amount of money. Well,
2:56actually,
2:57now we've got more information. We now realize that we need six developers
3:00costing, obviously,
3:01a slightly larger amount of money. So how does that change things? What impact
3:05does that change
3:06have because the underlying assumption has now changed? Next on our list,
3:10though, we have
3:11historical analysis. And this is where we examine the outcomes of similar
3:16previous initiatives. So
3:18if we just take a take a look at that then and see why that might be useful. So
3:21as I just said,
3:22this is where we take a look at other similar past programs. And this is going
3:27to help us out
3:28in two ways. So outcomes of similar previous programs can help with both
3:32decision making
3:33processes and with planning. For example, at the business case level, we might
3:39be able to
3:39illustrate to management that this wonderful program that we did, you know, a
3:44few years ago
3:44turned out fantastically. And this new program we're proposing has got many
3:48similarities, blah,
3:49blah, blah. It can illustrate to management that there's some repeatable
3:52success that we could
3:53put into play here. It could indicate that we have a greater chance of success
3:58of successfully
3:59completing this other similar program. And in terms of planning, if we look at
4:03other similar
4:04past initiatives, then it can help us understand what went well and what didn't
4:09go well in those
4:09other similar programs. We can learn from those lessons learned documentation
4:14to understand what
4:15unforeseen events occurred, where were the budget overruns, just as an example,
4:19why did they happen,
4:20what can we learn from that, how can we avoid those pitfalls in this program in
4:24order to make
4:25it more successful. With trend analysis next on our list here, well, this is
4:30where we forecast
4:31future results based on actual results that we have evidence for. So at the
4:36simplest level,
4:37it may be that let's look at a little chart here, we've got some actual results
4:42. Now, these might
4:43be from quality checks or whatever, but we've got some actual results that are
4:46happening right now.
4:47And then as I said, the simplest level, we might simply draw a trend line
4:50through that to anticipate
4:52what the future results might be if they were to follow the same trend. So at
4:57the simplest level,
4:58as I said, you're simply sticking a trend line on a chart there. The actual
5:01textbooks will say
5:02this much more grandly, they'll talk about using mathematical models to
5:06continue trends. But in the
5:08context of strategic alignment, this is going to help us look ahead for
5:12potential areas of
5:13misalignment with a view to giving us the opportunity is a bit of a heads up to
5:17correct any undesirable
5:19trends in order to minimize the impact of them. So, you know, we can take
5:22action to get back on
5:24track as it were. And then finally scenario analysis. So you can see here, this
5:30is all about the
5:31evaluation of possible scenarios in order to predict their effect. And I tend
5:35to think of scenario
5:36analysis as kind of like a game of what if. So we're asking ourselves the
5:41question,
5:41what if the situation represented by scenario X happens? And that scenario X is
5:48basically any
5:48risk that we've identified as something which might happen, which might impact
5:52our program.
5:53So yes, scenario analysis is an approach that we will use in our risk
5:58management activities.
5:59And the reason for the crystal ball and the fortune teller here is that
6:03scenario analysis is
6:04considered to be a forward looking approach because we consider a range of
6:08possible future outcomes
6:11based on the current uncertain conditions. The point being, of course, having
6:16peered into our
6:16crystal ball and considered these possible future outcomes, we're better able
6:20to develop
6:21effective risk management strategies in order to deal with them. So, there we
6:26go. That's all
6:27eight analysis techniques which we could be using in the strategic alignment
6:30performance domain.
Applying Skills and Knowledge to Strategic Alignment
0:00If you're preparing for the program management professional certification from
0:04the PMI,
0:04then you've probably got an eye on the exam content outline to give you
0:08guidance on what
0:09you might need to know for the exam.
0:11And indeed, in this video, I'd like us to pick up on some skills and knowledge
0:15listed
0:15on that outline and see how we might apply them to the performance domain of
0:20strategic
0:20alignment.
0:21And so if we just quickly look at that outline now, I'm going to pick up on one
0:25or two things
0:25from this list, which are listed as being specific to the strategic alignment
0:29domain,
0:29one, and you might notice that we have already covered most of these, and a few
0:34things from
0:34towards the end of this document as well, so some core skills and some other
0:38areas of
0:38knowledge.
0:39But I should also say, though, if you are not preparing for certification, then
0:43don't worry,
0:43I'm not going to be harping on about the exam.
0:45We're simply going to be exploring the strategic alignment domain from a
0:48slightly different
0:49angle and seeing how we will apply a variety of skills to it, all with the goal
0:53of improving
0:54your program management mindset and bolstering your understanding of what's
0:58involved in this
0:59domain.
1:00Now, when we discussed some aspects of the role of program manager, and one of
1:04the introductory
1:05skills in this course, we did see that in order to be effective in the program
1:09manager
1:10role, you had to have some really good business and financial know-how, and
1:14this was the slide
1:15we saw back then, but having that good solid business knowledge is a really
1:19important part
1:20of the role, especially when we see the number of entries on the exam outline
1:24to do with business.
1:25So let's run through some of these that I plucked from that document I showed
1:28you a second ago.
1:30So we need a good solid understanding of the business strategy and the business
1:34objectives
1:35for our organization.
1:37Otherwise, how can we ensure strategic alignment?
1:40I mean, our goal, of course, is to understand and to manage the way that our
1:45program plan
1:46fits in with the strategic plan of the organization and to ensure that we
1:50maintain alignment with
1:52that strategic plan.
1:54And it is such a shame, I think, sometimes when a program manager just gets
1:57given a program
1:58to manage in apparent isolation, you get this sometimes in very large
2:01businesses, somebody
2:02gets hired as a program manager to simply oversee and execute a collection of
2:07projects
2:08as it were.
2:09And I think that's a real shame that they don't get an opportunity to add the
2:12strategic
2:13alignment side of things, because I think this is an area where a program
2:16manager really
2:17can add value.
2:18You'll also see I've got business environment on the list here, so of course,
2:22we need to
2:23be continually monitoring the business environment that we are operating in.
2:28And there's quite a good little business catchphrase that you will sometimes
2:31see here, which is
2:32"vuka vuca".
2:34And this is a bit of a trendy buzzword, which basically means that our
2:37environment might
2:39be volatile, that's the V, uncertain, that's the U, the C is complex and the A
2:44is ambiguity.
2:46So sometimes when we are working in these vuka environments, we need to
2:49continually monitor
2:50them to understand its impact.
2:52And of course, we talked a little bit about some tools that we might be using
2:55to help us
2:56understand that, to analyze the environment, such as SWOT and PESTLE and what
3:00not.
3:01When it comes to business models, well, we're talking things like, you know, we
3:05might be
3:05operating with a subscription model or a retail model.
3:08It's understanding what the model is that our organization is using to do
3:11business.
3:12So of course, we need a solid understanding of our business model.
3:16But also, I think a general understanding of different business models as part
3:19of our
3:20business know-how in order to be effective in our role.
3:23Having an awareness of other business models can give us a greater depth of
3:27understanding
3:27as to what exactly makes a business tick.
3:30And then finally, business ethics.
3:32Well, when it comes to talking about ethical principles and moral or ethical
3:36problems that
3:37could arise in a business environment, well, it's all about doing the right
3:40thing, isn't
3:41it?
3:42And it is tricky because we've got to focus here on strategic alignment, so
3:45therefore
3:46canceling a project might be necessary in order to maintain strategic alignment
3:51.
3:51But that might mean people losing their jobs.
3:54And so we do need to act morally and ethically in these tricky business
3:59situations.
4:00But next on my list, I've got executive level presentation.
4:04And let's think of this in the context of presenting a business case or getting
4:08the
4:08programme charter approved.
4:10And this might be your only shot to present to senior management.
4:13So you've got to get it right.
4:15They are busy people.
4:16If you mess it up, they're not likely to say, oh, don't worry, come back and
4:20have another
4:20go next week.
4:21So we need to make sure that we talk their language as it were.
4:25We need to show them how the programme contributes to the organisation's
4:30mission and vision.
4:32And if you think about this, as programme managers, we are uniquely positioned
4:37to link
4:38the business strategy to the programme's outcomes.
4:41We need to be crystal clear on why senior management needs to consider this
4:45programme.
4:46And once we have clarified the why and, you know, that they're bought in, the
4:51first question
4:52they're going to ask is, well, how much is this going to cost and how long will
4:55it take?
4:56So you need to be ready with those answers.
4:59You need to be clear and succinct.
5:01They are busy people.
5:02You've got to cut the chase and provide the top level information that they
5:06need in order
5:06to be able to make a decision.
5:08But do be ready to provide backup information if required, but equally be ready
5:13to summarise
5:14if you do get drawn into another level of detail.
5:16You've got to be really sensitive as to whether lengthy side tracks are really
5:19what they're
5:20interested in or not.
5:22And an important part of all of this will be managing expectations.
5:26And of course, the skill of managing expectations could be exercised at any
5:30time throughout
5:31the programme lifecycle in many different ways, and it will apply to all
5:35domains.
5:35But in the context of the business case and the charter, we need to manage
5:39expectations
5:40around the level of detail we're able to provide at that early stage of the
5:44programme.
5:45For example, we might get a senior executive saying, I can't authorise this
5:50programme
5:50until I know exactly how much it's going to cost.
5:55And so yes, we need to set some expectations here because those estimates are
5:59going to
6:00become more accurate as planning progresses.
6:03And there is a cost associated with the next level of planning, isn't there?
6:07You know, we need the thumbs up to go ahead and plan a bit further before those
6:10estimates
6:11will become more accurate.
6:12So it's about setting expectations that at this early stage, these are just
6:15estimates.
6:16And we need to be very clear about what assumptions that we have made.
6:19And we need to reassure them that, yeah, we will revise and review these
6:23assumptions.
6:24Remember that assumptions analysis that we talked about in the last video, I
6:27think.
6:27We need to understand that different stakeholders will have different
6:30priorities, so therefore
6:31their expectations will be different.
6:33And they'll have different requirements that have different priorities in their
6:36minds.
6:36They'll have different appetite for risk, for example.
6:39And therefore we do need to be very transparent about risk.
6:42We need to explain those high level risks.
6:44And we also need them to understand that we're going to be expanding on this
6:47initial risk
6:48assessment in order to build a robust risk management strategy.
6:52And that risk is going to be monitored and managed throughout the entire
6:55programme lifecycle.
6:56But at this stage, we've just got high level risks.
7:00But anyway, I sidetracked onto this managing expectations skill after talking
7:03about executive
7:04level presentation.
7:06But in addition to that, we do have listed presentation tools and techniques.
7:11And of course, we could have a whole separate course on presentation tools and
7:14techniques,
7:15but just a few points to note here.
7:17So firstly, be prepared.
7:19Practice really does make perfect.
7:21Even experienced presenters should run through the presentation in advance
7:25because great presentations
7:26don't happen by mistake.
7:28And it does take time to put together an effective presentation.
7:31For example, if you're putting together slides, then you need to put time aside
7:34to create
7:35those slides.
7:36And don't forget you don't have to use slides at all.
7:38There are other ways of giving a presentation.
7:41Consider what your audience needs to know.
7:43Be careful about having just one generic status update presentation that you
7:47use for
7:48everybody.
7:49Different audiences will want different levels of detail.
7:51They'll have different priorities.
7:52So consider the needs of your audience.
7:54Make sure you are familiar with the tools that you're using so it could be as
7:57simple
7:58as using PowerPoint effectively.
8:00But if you're using some sort of video conferencing tool, then you need to be
8:02confident sharing
8:03your screen and making sure that you can share your slides.
8:07If you're using equipment in a presentation room that's using a projector or a
8:10microphone,
8:11then you need to make sure that you are prepared and you're organized and you
8:13know how to use
8:14the kit.
8:16And then finally, use visual representations rather than text wherever you can.
8:23And I was messing with you here.
8:25But look at this slide.
8:26How did you feel about what you were looking at while I was talking just now?
8:30Because there was no animation nor any visual indicators as to which bullet
8:34point I was
8:34talking about at any one time was there.
8:36You couldn't help it read ahead could you?
8:38And not only were there no visual markers on this slide to keep you with me,
8:41but there's
8:42nothing on here to differentiate this slide from potentially 10 other slides of
8:46plain text
8:47bullets.
8:48Well, not until I added the little laughing face anyway.
8:50And if you've got lots of slides that look like this, then you really do have
8:53death by
8:54PowerPoint.
8:55But it does take time to put together an effective presentation.
8:59You know, choosing the graphics, creating diagrams, using animation.
9:03Believe you me, my manager sometimes asked me, why did that skill take you so
9:06long?
9:07And I can honestly say that creating my visuals was a big chunk of the time
9:10taken.
9:11That's one reason why we use the scribbles so extensively on our slides and our
9:14chalkboards.
9:15It's a really time efficient way to add some visual interest and to keep you
9:18with us as
9:19we're explaining stuff to you.
9:21And when I was talking through this slide without using anything extra, I had
9:24to really sit on
9:24my hands to not add the extra scribbles while I was talking through this boring
9:28slide.
9:29But anyway, for us, a good example of a visual representation rather than text
9:33is going to
9:34be the roadmap.
9:35So this is clearly a visual representation of how the components of the program
9:40might
9:40map out and where the milestones and the key decision points might be.
9:45So compare what you're looking at now to a text based version of a similar
9:48thing.
9:49I mean dreadful, absolutely dreadful.
9:51And to illustrate the problem of having lots of text based slides one after the
9:55other, well,
9:56this is all about the program roadmap, supposedly.
9:59There's that original slide about the presentation tools and techniques.
10:02If I just go back to the roadmap one, back to the presentation techniques, they
10:06just look
10:06the same.
10:07There's nothing that makes them stand out.
10:09So slides like this are horrible.
10:11Next on my list though is facilitation.
10:14Now presenting is a different skill to facilitation.
10:18So what we mean by facilitation is well, we're not presenting, we're not in
10:22broadcast mode,
10:23we're facilitating some kind of collaborative session such as running a meeting
10:27or a brainstorm
10:28or a problem solving workshop or a focus group, et cetera.
10:32And again, we could have a whole separate course on facilitation skills, but
10:36just to
10:36get you thinking, first of all, prepare.
10:39So make sure that you do invite the right people and consider the room layout
10:44of the
10:44place you're going to run this session, whatever it might be.
10:47So theatre style, for example, might be suitable for presentation, but not for
10:51a session where
10:51you're expecting interaction.
10:53So something I think like this would be much better, a U-shape configuration
10:57like this
10:57where people have got desks to write on, particularly if you've got activities
11:00for them to do during
11:02the session.
11:03And if you have got activities that you want them to do, maybe you want them to
11:06write stuff
11:06off on flip chart paper or write things on post-it notes, then you need to have
11:10those
11:10props ready.
11:12You need to, again, be comfortable with the tools that you're using, whether
11:15they're
11:15electronic tools, maybe for an online session, and you need to have decided on
11:19the timings
11:20and the agenda and the structure of the session in advance.
11:23We also need to make sure everybody is clear on the goal of the session.
11:27So you've gathered everybody together for some kind of interactive meeting,
11:30whatever
11:30it might be.
11:31Well, you've got to be really sure that they know why they are there.
11:35What is the problem we're solving?
11:36Or what is it that we're supposed to be brainstorming on?
11:38We need to understand why we're there.
11:40And depending on the type of session it is, you might need to set some ground
11:44rules.
11:45So if it is a problem solving workshop, then potentially tensions might be
11:48running high.
11:49We have to help people behave in a way that's going to be productive.
11:53So maybe you say, right, no phones in this session, or maybe we say, look, you
11:57never disregard
11:58somebody else's input.
11:59We respect everybody's contributions.
12:02And then when we're facilitating any type of collaborative meeting, we need to
12:06actively manage
12:07participation and interaction.
12:10So who needs encouragement to share their view and who needs to shut up?
12:14You know, it's up to us to manage that.
12:16If there is somebody that's talking too much, if they're stopping other people
12:19from talking,
12:20then we need to say to them, you know, thank you for your contribution, Wendy.
12:23I think Lula actually has got something to say now.
12:25We need to be brave enough to do that.
12:28And all of these facilitation techniques will apply when it comes to brainstorm
12:33ing, which
12:33is yet another thing from our list of possible skills.
12:36So brainstorming, of course, is an efficient way of generating a wide range of
12:41ideas from
12:42a variety of different perspectives.
12:44And I think we can safely say that the SWOT analysis and the PESTLE analysis is
12:49going
12:49to be very much examples of brainstorming we might do in the strategic
12:54alignment domain.
12:55And an example of a ground rule that you might want to set as per the fac
12:59ilitation tips
13:00would be this, forbid the NO-BUT response to an idea.
13:05Let's imagine you're running a brainstorm to try and solve a problem.
13:08And somebody says, hey, how about we do this?
13:11And then somebody else says, oh, no, but that'll never work.
13:14We need to forbid that type of response because it means that the poor person
13:18that just tried
13:18to contribute then, you know, probably isn't going to say anything else again
13:21for the rest
13:21of the session.
13:23Because this is the type of interaction that we want in a brainstorming session
13:27.
13:27Every idea, any idea is a good idea.
13:30And we need to bounce ideas off each other rather than saying, oh, no, that'll
13:34never
13:34work.
13:35And then finally, we need to potentially be inventive about how we can
13:39encourage participation,
13:41particularly in the case of HIP-O.
13:43Now, have you heard of HIP-O?
13:44So HIP-O means the highest paid person's opinion.
13:47So the danger of having senior executives in a brainstorming session means that
13:52their
13:52opinion wins.
13:53I mean, if a chief executive says, oh, I think we should do this, well, who am
13:57I to
13:57say?
13:58Well, actually, I think it might be even better if we did that.
14:00So we need to be quite careful about this and be aware of the different people
14:05in the room.
14:06We might need to get inventive about how we get people to share their ideas.
14:10Maybe we get them to write things up on flip charts.
14:13Maybe we get them to write things on bits of paper anonymously.
14:15Lots of different ideas we could use to ensure participation from everybody.
14:21My goodness, that was a bit of a mammoth video.
14:23I am well aware that we covered a lot of ground there.
14:26So I'm not going to go through all of these again on the key takeaways.
14:28But just take a moment to reflect on this list here of the things that we
14:32talked about.
14:33And just remind yourself in your own mind as to how we might apply these skills
14:37and
14:37knowledge in the strategic alignment performance domain.
Challenge
0:00Okay, let's run through the answers then. Starting with task number one,
0:04perform an initial
0:05program assessment by defining the program objectives, requirements and risks
0:09to ensure
0:09program alignment with the d-d-d-d-d-d-d-organizations strategic plan. So
0:13hopefully that was quite an easy one.
0:16Number two here, establish a what kind of roadmap. Well, it is going to be high
0:21level. I mean, it's
0:23certainly not detailed. I suppose draft might have been kind of correct, but
0:26high level
0:27is the term that we do tend to use in this context. Number three here, evaluate
0:32the
0:32program's what to develop, validate and assess the program objectives, priority
0:37, feasibility,
0:38readiness and alignment with the organization's strategic plan. Now your clue
0:42here was feasibility,
0:44because you might be thinking, oh, you know, is this the charter, is this the
0:47business case,
0:47but since you see feasibility, then that means we're talking about the business
0:51case. So that was
0:52the answer that I was after. Number four here, estimate the high level what and
0:57non-financial
0:58benefits, blah, blah, blah. Well, this was the high level financial framework.
1:03That's the term we
1:03see in the textbooks. You will remember from the last skill that this maps out
1:07the expected flow
1:08of funding for our program. And we will be creating this in the in the early
1:12stages of the life
1:13cycle. It's high level at this stage, but we will build upon it. And also, one
1:18of these tasks
1:19do mention benefits. For example, this mentions non-financial benefits. Now we
1:23're going to come
1:23back to talking in more detail about benefits because there's a whole separate
1:27performance
1:27domain on benefits. So if you wonder why I've glossed over, glossed over
1:31benefits, then don't
1:32worry, we're coming back to that. But task number five here, my goodness, you
1:36had three gaps to fill
1:37in. So the first gap, obtain organizational leadership, what approval for the
1:42program by
1:43presenting the what? Well, it's the charter that we present for approval. And
1:47that means we get
1:48authorization to initiate the program. And I bet you are looking for the word
1:53begin or start or even
1:55plan from the list of choices in the quiz question. But this task has been
1:59lifted directly from the
2:01PMI exam content outline. And yes, initiate is the word that they used. I hope
2:06this has been informative
2:07for you. And I'd like to thank you for viewing.
Team training path
Turn this skill into assignable team training
This free skill is a preview of the courses your team can assign, track, and report on with CBT Nuggets.
$708
seat / year